ISSN  1999-8864  (Online)
 

  最新卷期
Current Issue
  第五卷 第二期
Vol.5 No.2
  所有卷期
All Issues
  投稿須知
For Authors
 
第五卷 第二期 Volume 5 Number 2 [完整版 | Entire Version] 

主編的話 黃政傑 王麗雲
Editors' Note Jenq-Jye Hwang   Li-Yun Wang
 
Content Analysis of Energy and Climate Change Concepts in Elementary and Middle School Science Textbooks Yao-Ting Sung   Hsin-Tsun Huang   Hsueh-Chih Chen
摘要 Abstract | 全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
能源與氣候變遷概念之內容分析──以自然與生活科技領域為例
摘要 Abstract

  本研究分析比較九十八學年度國小與國中自然與生活科技學習領域教科書中有關能源與氣候變遷的概念。
  研究團隊以能源與氣候變遷專家概念圖中52個被區分為國小與國中學習階段的主要概念及其他輔助概念為關鍵字依據,透過檢索與記錄相關概念在3個主要版本的教科書文本中出現的年級、章節、段落,並比較各版本中主要概念出現的階段是否符合專家的建議;同時,分析概念圖中5個主題概念在各版本的繼續性及順序性。
  結果顯示,國小內容符合專家分類國小階段主要概念的比例以康軒版較低;國中內容符合專家分類國中階段主要概念的比例在各版本教科書中皆偏低,顯示目前國中內容相關概念極待補充。其次,5個主題概念在各版本的順序性與繼續性比較:「能源」主題以南一版較佳;「氣候變遷現象導致的衝擊」主題,各版本的表現皆不佳;其餘3個主題則以翰林版表現較佳。
  In this study, we analyzed energy and climate change concepts in elementary and middle school science textbooks. A conceptual map drawn up by specialists was chosen as the criteria for locating relevant concepts in textbooks. It was composed of 52 main concepts and some supplementary concepts divided by experts into elementary and middle school learning levels. We recorded grade levels, chapters, and paragraphs containing relevant concepts in textbooks. The recorded concepts were then examined to determine whether they conformed to the correct levels. Three textbook versions, including the Kang Hsuan, Nan-I, and Han Ling versions, were analyzed.
  At the elementary school level, findings showed that the Kang Hsuan version needs to increase content on climate change more than the other versions. At the middle school level, all three versions were similarly deficient of content, but the number of concepts was lower than that suggested by experts. We also analyzed continuity and sequence of five subject concepts presented in different versions. The Nan-I version presented better on the subject of energy. None of the three versions met the criteria on the impact of climate change. Han Ling presented better on the rest of three subject concepts.
引註 APA Format
宋曜廷、黃信樽、陳學志(2012)。能源與氣候變遷概念之內容分析──以自然與生活科技領域為例。教科書研究5(2),1-30。
 
 
Analysis of Statistical Content in Junior High School Mathematics Textbooks Based on Statistical Cognition and Graph Comprehension Kin-Hang Lei   Kai-Lin Yang
摘要 Abstract | 全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
從統計認知面向與圖表理解角度分析國中數學教科書的統計內容
摘要 Abstract

  依據文獻上的統計認知面向與圖表理解,以內容分析法探討2種配合九二課綱編排的國中數學教科書版本中的統計內容。研究發現,2種版本的教科書都能提供學生各種統計知識的學習機會,但是在統計推理和統計思考方面的能力培養較為不足;而2種版本教科書的統計圖表,皆提供學生從認識圖表的元素以及圖表所呈現的資訊解讀圖表的能力。但是少有讓學生對圖像資訊做延伸推論或依據需要選擇合適的方式來呈現圖表的學習機會。這可能是因為和統計主題相關的能力指標,大多著重於統計知識的認識、圖表的繪製以及資訊的直接讀取。因此,建議教科書可考慮增加統計推理與統計思考、選用圖表和利用圖像資訊做推論等學習任務,讓學生能更深入地學習統計概念以及應用統計圖表做推理分析。
  Content analysis was used to investigate statistical cognition and graph comprehension of two textbooks edited according to 2003 curriculum guidelines. We found that the two textbooks provide substantial learning opportunities for statistical literacy; however, they provide almost no learning opportunities for statistical reasoning and thinking. Furthermore, both of the textbooks provide learning opportunities to interpret graphs by recognizing components and information displayed in graphs, but provide almost no learning opportunities to infer from graphs or choose proper graphs for different situations. This may be because the guidelines only focus on knowing statistical knowledge, drawing graphs, and retrieving information directly. To enhance the ability of students to apply statistical graphs and concepts for making inferences, it is recommended to provide students with tasks for reasoning and thinking statistically, selecting graphs and making inference by analyzing information of graphs.
引註 APA Format
李健恆、楊凱琳(2012)。從統計認知面向與圖表理解角度分析國中數學教科書的統計內容。教科書研究5(2),31-72。
 
 
Comparison of Student Roles Described in Elementary-School Mandarin Textbooks Released by Different Publishers between 1990 and 2010 Ding-Ying Guo
摘要 Abstract | 全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
不同版本國小國語教科書中學生角色之比較──以民國80與90年代為例
摘要 Abstract

  本研究旨在探討臺灣教科書開放後,比較80、90 年代不同版本國小國語教科書中所呈學生角色頻次之異同。透過內容分析法,共計辨識學生角色陳述頻次1916 次,再以SPSS for Windows 14.0套裝軟體中次數分配及卡方檢定進行資料分析。結果發現:(一)教科書開放政策之後,雖然各版本在學生角色出現頻次有其獨特性,但三大角色內涵之排序相同,顯示在學生角色知識地圖並未重構;(二)不同版本國小國語教科書對3項學生角色內涵的描述頻次,並非80年代教科書一開放就有明顯差異,而是隨著時間,各出版社經由編修而演化出不同的描述頻次。根據以上結論,本研究提出「宜多肯定教科書書開放之意義」、「針對不同版本教科書之內容,適時融入或補充相關教材,以培養合宜之學生角色」、「未來研究可再針對不同版本間學生角色內涵,進行質性的比較分析」等建議。
  This study compares how often the role of students appeared in Mandarin textbooks used in elementary schools after the implementation of the opening up policy. Using the content analysis method, the role of student was identified a total of 1916 times in these textbooks. The data were subsequently analyzed by frequency and Chi-square test and calculated on SPSS for Windows 14.0. The findings of this study are summarized as follows:
  1. Although each version is unique in its own way, all the textbooks after the opening up policy were identical in ranking in three dimensions of student role. This study clearly indicates that the knowledge map in student role was not reconstructed after the implementation of the opening up policy for textbook.
  2. The number of times three student-role categories were not significantly different among the versions published in the 1990s. Posterior to publishers’ revision, however, different versions published between 1990 and 2010 had different frequencies to describe three student-role categories.
    Recommendations from this study are also offered.
引註 APA Format
郭丁熒(2012)。不同版本國小國語教科書中學生角色之比較──以民國80與90年代為例。教科書研究5(2),73-101。
 
 
中日英語教科書之元話語分析 Linfeng Wang
摘要 Abstract | 全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
A Comparative Study of the Metadiscourse Analysis in EFL Textbooks in Japan and China
摘要 Abstract

  本研究旨在從元話語(metadiscourse)的觀點來分析中日英語教科書中編者是如何向學習者傳達與學習有關的資訊。本研究基於Crismore(1983)元話語的分析框架對中日四個出版社的國中一年級英語教科書進行分析,進而展示出教科書中的元話語是如何幫助和影響學習者對學習內容以及對學習要求的理解。分析方法主要是從資訊元話語、態度元話語、母語與目的語的使用、附錄以及中小學連結五個方面來展開。分析結果表明,雖然中日英語教科書同屬於英語作為外國語的教科書範疇,但是二者在元對話的使用方面呈現出不同風格與特徵,從而揭示出二者在教科書設計理念方面的不同價值取向。在對教科書元話語分析結果的闡釋中,本文參照了中日兩國國家英語課程標準的有關方面來展開論述。
  The purpose of this study is to examine the use of metadiscourse in seventh-grade English textbooks in Japan and China in the context of calls for more learner-friendly textbooks. Four textbooks were selected for metadiscourse analysis to determine what kinds of metadiscourse are used to facilitate or affect learner understanding of propositional content. Focusing on metadiscourse’s pedagogical function, Crismore’s (1983) metadiscourse typology for textbooks and other relevant elements were taken into account. The findings imply that although both Japan and China are categorized as EFL countries, their English textbooks display different characteristics in terms of metadiscourse usage, reflecting the different ways in which learning materials are designed and developed. In order to interpret these findings, the impacts of national curricula are discussed.
引註 APA Format
Linfeng Wang(2012)。A Comparative Study of the Metadiscourse Analysis in EFL Textbooks in Japan and China。教科書研究5(2),103-123。
 

Textbook Reform in the New Era of Compulsory Education
全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
引註 APA Format
論壇:新國教下談教科書變革。教科書研究5(2),125-151。
 

Tyranny of the Textbook: An Insider Exposes How Educational Materials Undermine Reforms
Ya-Hsuan Wang
全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
引註 APA Format
王雅玄(2012)。書評:教科書專制──一個局內人揭露教材如何暗中破壞改革。教科書研究5(2),153-164。
 

報導 REPORT
2012東亞歷史教科書共構工作坊 詹美華 陳姵琁
2012 Workshop on Joint Construction of East Asia Supplementary History Textbook
Mei-Hua Zhan   Pei-Hsuan Chen
全文 PDF Full Text | 引註 How to Cite |
引註 APA Format
詹美華、陳姵琁(2012)。報導:2012東亞歷史教科書共構工作坊。教科書研究5(2),165-175。
 
 

本刊投稿及編務事宜連絡,請函寄:10644臺北市大安區和平東路一段179號4樓,或E-mail:ej@mail.naer.edu.tw
 
Manuscripts and all editorial correspondence should be sent to:
4F, 179 Sec. 1, Heping E. Rd., Daan Dist., Taipei City 10644, Taiwan (R.O.C.), or E-mail:ej@mail.naer.edu.tw

Creative Commons License   Directory of Open Access Journals   EBSCO Education Research Complete    臺灣社會科學引文索引